Skip to main content

How to Get Timestamped Feedback on Your Mixes

“The vocal gets buried around the second chorus.” Every producer has had that note, and has then scrubbed through the mix guessing which second chorus, and how far into it. A note without a time costs a listen to decode, and sometimes a revision that fixes the wrong thing.

This guide covers how to send mixes so the people giving notes can pin each one to a track and a moment, and how to read them back in the order the song plays.

Why “around the second chorus” costs you a revision

Notes on a mix arrive the way people talk: the snare feels loud in the bridge, can the intro be shorter, love the new version. The useful part, where in which song, is the part that gets lost. On a single you can usually find it. On a six-track EP with three rounds of mixes, you end up asking follow-up questions, and the artist ends up answering from memory.

Two things fix most of it: a time on every note that is about a moment, and one place where all the notes land, sorted by track.

What people use today

  • An email thread about a shared folder link. The mixes live in a cloud folder and the notes live in the replies. Everyone writes times their own way, if they write them at all, and by the third round the notes on v2 and v3 are in the same thread.
  • SoundCloud's timed comments. On SoundCloud's website, clicking below a track's waveform posts a comment at that point in the track. It is the closest thing to a timed note many artists have used. SoundCloud is built around public tracks, so before you put unreleased mixes there, check who will be able to read the comments.

Whatever you use, three things matter: notes tied to a moment, all of them in one place, and a link that only the people you chose can open.

Step by step

1. Upload the mixes as a release

Create a release for the round of mixes (call it “EP mixes v2”, say) and upload a track for each song. WAV and FLAC files upload as they are, and phones get an MP3 copy so playback starts quickly; our guide to sharing WAV files has the details.

Keep each round in its own release, so each set of notes stays with the mix it is about. If you use Replace Audio on a track instead, its earlier notes stay on that track, and their times then point into the new mix.

2. Lock it before you switch it on

Mixes are not for the public. Before you turn on the release's Share link switch, add a password, or an invite list of the email addresses allowed to open it. Someone on an invite list confirms their address with a one-time code. Protected releases are never listed on your public artist page, so the link you send is the only way in; what a private release looks like shows what everyone else sees. The first time you switch sharing on, you are asked to confirm you have the rights to share the music.

3. Turn on Collect Feedback

In the release's Share Settings, under Feedback, switch on Collect Feedback. Only the artist's owner can change Share Settings, so if a collaborator set up the release, the owner switches this one.

4. Send the link

Send the link to whoever is giving notes. They do not need a Gatefolded account. Once they are past the password or the invite check, a feedback form sits below the player. For each note they can:

  • leave it on the whole release, or pick a track;
  • add a time, typed like 1:42 (1:02:05 or plain seconds work too);
  • press Use player position, which fills in the track they are playing and where they are in it;
  • add their name and email, both optional.

Comments are private. Nobody else who opens the link sees them.

5. Read the notes by track and time

Comments appear in the release's Share Settings, under Feedback. Comments on the whole release come first, then each track in order, with its timed notes in song order, so you can work through a mix from top to bottom with the session open. Each note shows its time, the name (or Anonymous), the email if they gave one, and the date.

6. Act on the bell

When a comment comes in, the bell on your dashboard shows a New listener feedback notice naming the release. Clicking it opens the release at the comments. A run of comments is one notice until you read it; the next comment after that brings a new one.

Passing demos around the band

The same setup works before anyone outside the band hears a thing. Add your bandmates as members of the artist (up to five people, counting the owner), upload the demos, lock the release and turn on feedback. The artist's owner and every member can read the notes in Share Settings, and each of them gets the bell notice.

To leave notes themselves, bandmates open the share link like anyone else and use the same form, so send it to them too.

What it doesn't do

  • No replies or threads. A note is a single message. Talk it through the way you already do.
  • No way to mark a note done. Keep your own list as you work through them.
  • No email alerts for feedback. New comments show up in the bell.
  • No public comments. Comments are never shown to other listeners.

A checklist before you send

  • One release per round of mixes, named so you can tell them apart.
  • A password or an invite list on before the Share link goes on.
  • Collect Feedback on (the artist's owner switches it).
  • Downloads left off unless someone needs the files. A new release starts with them off.
  • Open the link on your own phone, play a track and try Use player position yourself.
  • Ask people to put a time on any note about a moment.

The FAQ answer on listener feedback covers the details, and feedback is included in the one plan on the pricing page.

Get notes you can act on

Start your free trial. Upload a round of mixes, lock it, and send a link that collects timestamped notes.

Try Gatefolded free